Saturday, 6 December 2014

Favourites : Van Morrison : Wavelength

It is not fashionable amongst Van Morrison fans to say you like Wavelength.  While it is not may favourite Van album - that would be a hard choice between about three or four (or maybe five or six albums) Wavelength is up there for me.

There you go - I said it - a guilty pleasure. Sure his lyrics are not up to his best, sure the band sounds like session musicians waiting for their paycheck.  However the album just seems to bounce along and for that I am happy!

Standout tracks for me include Wavelength  (this is a nice version from a DVD I have), Kingdom Hall, Take it Where You Find It, Natalia, and Santa Fe/Beautiful Obsession which had been around for about 10 years before it was recorded - here is an early version.


Wednesday, 3 December 2014

Song of the Day 39 : Amphetamine : Steve Wynn

I first heard/saw Amphetamine on a late night music TV show.  It then came out on an Uncut CD sampler.  I was blown away by such a good driving rock song which I had thought had all but but become extinct by then (2003).  I ended up getting the album it came from and really enjoying that and going back and getting more of Steve Wynn's catalogue.

However it is this song that is always the touch stone.  What a great party song - it can even survive the Disney Treatment - almost

Favourites : Bill Mallonee and the Vigilantes of Love : Audible Sigh

I imported this Audible Sigh after hearing the track Resplendent on a compilation album.  An added bonus when it arrived was it came with an extra CD of demos and other songs.   As with a lot of music there were immediately a connection I had not expected with Buddy Miller producing.

Some very good songs  on the album including Nothing like a train, Goes without saying, She walks on roses, and Now as the Train Pulls Away



This is a very good album that deserved wider airing and recognition.  However that is the way of the music business.  I bought the follow up CD and was not that taken with it so have not really followed his career since - but a quick check on Amazon reveals he is still recording and releasing albums.  Should check him out again.

Tuesday, 2 December 2014

Favourites : Buddy and Julie Miller : Written in Chalk

I have been listening to Buddy Miller and his music since buying his  album Cruel Moon on the recommendation from a guy that ran, Allen's a small record store at the top of Plimmers Steps (Taking me back to those trips into Chelsea Records 40 years ago!).

Shortly after that I saw a short set by him when he was playing guitar in Emmylou Harris's band and also opening with a short 30 minute set.  I loved Emmylou that night but that short set from Buddy was the highlight for me.

It was while playing for Emmylou that Buddy started to get recognition after years of banging around Nashville.  He has since gone on to produce Robert Plant, Richard Thompson and Solomon Burke.  Its pretty cool when your record collection starts to talk to itself!

Written in Chalk in the second proper Buddy and Julie Miller album,  The first one did not grab me - maybe my expectations were too high. When it was released I had solo albums by both of them which frequently had jointly written and sung songs on them that were frequently the highlights.

When this album came out it got great reviews but I was still weary.  I did not have to be.  I think this is a modern country masterpiece.  From the opening two tracks Ellis County and Gasoline and Matches,  the almost title track Chalk and Everytime We Say Goodbye


Favourites : Paul Kelly Under The Sun

While the sprawling double lp Gossip was my introduction to Paul Kelly Under The Sun is the one I come back to the most.

Kelly is a very literate songwriter who ranks as one of the best of his generation.  One of those artists that you forget for a while and then you play a CD or album and go on a bit of a binge.  I think it happens because while the songwriting is such a uniformly high standard the delivery is such that binging eventually has you putting them to the side for a while.  Hiatt, Springsteen, Zevon and Waits are all in the same category as far as I am concerned.

I have managed to see him three times.  The most memorable at Sammy's in Dunedin about 20 years ago!!!

Under the Sun is crammed with outstanding songs.  The highlight to me is To Her Door a gentle song of relationship redemption.  Dumb Things and 40 Miles to Saturday Night are great party songs with the latter always bringing Jon's time "stranded" in the outback to mind.  The CD version of the album has the mighty Bradman on it - the best song about cricket ever.   I still have strong memories of the crowd that night singing along to it waving their arms in the air as he sang the "Pal,m of His Hands" lyric (and this was a NZ audience!)

Playing the album now - I feel a binge coming on.



Sunday, 30 November 2014

Song of the Day 38 : Grand Canyon ; Drive By Truckers

In my opinion in the last 10 years the mighty Drive By Truckers has only made one below par album (The Big To Do).  However this year's  English Oceans album has been hailed a return to form by many.   One of the reasons for that is undoubtedly because of this song.

Written in memory of a friend - it makes a fitting memorial.

A blog on the whole album - is still coming

Saturday, 29 November 2014

Song of the Day 37 Come Rain or Come Shine : Ray Charles

The first time I heard Come Rain or Come Shine by Ray Charles on the Soundtrack to Martin Scorsese's King of Comedy.    It was the start of my journey into Charles' music and remains one of my favourite songs by the man. Can be found on the album The Genius of Ray Charles

Journey Through The Past 43 : Iggy Pop New Values

New Values was part of the soundtrack to my first year of flatting at university in Christchurch.

It was Iggy embracing the new wave with a poppy selection of solid if rather meaningless and even dumb songs.  I do not listen to it often but when I do I surprise myself by still knowing most of the words.

It does not get mentioned very often in assessments of Iggy's work coming immediately

The album has a few interesting tracks including Five Foot One, Girls, Don't look down (which Bowie remade).

I'm Bored is probably the best known song on the album.  Interestingly he recorded another video of it when in NZ for Radio With Pictures at a (NZ) celebrities type of event.  Here that is and clearly no one really knew what to make of him at the time as he tried to shock (in a pretty lame way).  He was clearly pretty bored!!!  I knew a guy that was there recording it and he said it was like a complete cultural mismatch.


Friday, 28 November 2014

Recent Additions : LC Cooke - The SAR Recordings

LC Cooke is Sam Cooke's brother and these are recordings he made between 1959 and 1965.  The similarities with his brother are strong especially on the tracks that were written by Sam for LC and at times this sounds like the great lost Sam Cooke Album.

Originally intended to be released just before Sam died the first ten tracks were shelved and only released this year on this package along with a few tracks recorded both before and after.

Standout tracks include Put Me Down Easy and If Only I Could Hear.


Wednesday, 26 November 2014

Favourites : Too Long in the Wasteland : James McMurtry

From the late 70's to the mid 80's writer Larry McMurtry seemed to be everywhere with best selling books, movies and TV shows like The Last Picture Show, Terms of Endearment and Lonesome Dove.  The latter was a particularly good TV Mini-Series (remember them?) portraying a gritty western story like Gus and Cap'n Call.  In that time I probably read at least 10 of his books.

Too Long in the Wasteland is Larry's Son's debut album, recorded in 1989 with John Mellencamp at the helm.  Mellencamp also generously lent his band to support as well.


On release the album got good reviews and James' heritage was almost always mentioned in the accompanying story.  The connection itself was a good enough reason for me to overlook the Mellencamp connection and buy the album.  I was not disappointed.  here is a selection of some of the tracks I enjoy the most; Talkin' at the Texaco where you can just get that small town US vibe,
I'm not from here for anyone who has lived in tourist town, Too Long in the wasteland and
Painting By Numbers where you can check out a very young David Letterman.

Tuesday, 25 November 2014

Favourites : T Bone Burnett : The Criminal Beneath My Own Hat

I first became aware of T Bone Burnett as the producer behind early Los Lobos and Blasters Albums. I wrote about him earlier in this blog as one of the producers whose work I have been following for 30 or more years.

Early on he was really championing the new roots style music that morphed over 20 years to Americana or Alternative Country.  Any press about him at that time also mentioned that he was a member of Dylan's Rolling Thunder Review.  Then he appeared with Elvis Costello as one half of The Coward Brothers who released a one off single The People's Limousine and then he produced Costello's magnificent King of America album.

In short for a while he was everywhere.

I picked up a few albums in sale bins and nothing ever quite clicked.  He has a think weedy voice and his stories and songs are generally a little eccentric in subject matter and delivery.  Not that I did not enjoy his stuff -   However this album changed that for me at least.  A very solid album - the eccentricity was wound back - just a little and he pulled together a great set of songs.  Starting with
It's Not Too LateHumans From Earth was used on a few soundtracks and Tear This Building Down and Over You are just good simple songs.

Since recording the album he has concentrated more on his production (which as he has gotten more famous I seem to enjoy less as the clarity and life he once brought now seem drowned in bass and reverb - notably on the Robert Plant - Raising Sand album) and his soundtrack work with the Cohen Brothers (notably the great bluegrass on Oh Brother Where Art Thou).  

Sunday, 23 November 2014

Favourites : Julian Cope : Jehovahkill and Peggy Suicide

Julian Cope fans are divided on what his greatest album is.  The Teardrop Explodes official last album Wilder, the environmentally focussed Peggy Suicide and some, like me, even go for this one Jehovahkill.

I first came across Julian Cope with Teardrop Explodes' first album, Kilimanjaro in 1981.

The story/myth was that the Teardrops imploded after Cope became more and more erratic as he experimented more and more with LSD. Courtney Love may even had something to with it as she had latched herself onto Julian and supposedly, and unsurprisingly, was not popular with the rest of the band.

In some respects he could be considered in a similar vein to Neil Young in the singular and eccentric path he has followed since leaving the band (now more than 30 years ago).  Seemingly recording music to please himself he has at times been very prolific.  His live shows by reputation can be stunning, frustrating or both.



His first two solo albums seemed to support the LSD theory being disjointed and erratic then with Saint Julian and My Nation Underground he produces two albums clearly targeted at commercial success (maybe just to get some $ to fund his growing literary and scholarly pursuits.  At the time he was researching a book on Stone Circles in the UK which along with a follow up similar tome on prehistoric structures in Europe mean that he is now recognised as a leading figure on the antiquities.

After the commercial success of the St Julian and My Nation Underground he produced a couple very noncommercial albums before the one two hit of Peggy Suicide and Jehovahkill.  The former with strong environmental theme and the latter clearly influenced by his fascination with the antiquities and his intense dislike of christianity.

Both were double albums and both had a mixture of soft acoustic tracks and rockers equally influenced by his love of Krautrock and The Stooges.  Both also hang together remarkably well considering their ambitious themes, testimony to both Cope's intellectual and music abilities.

There are so many good songs on these albums it is really hard to recommend where to start.  Some won't like the electric workouts, others the seemingly banal repetition of some songs but they are always interesting and well worth checking out. Julian Cope is a very singular artist and it is great that he has managed to work out how to continue following his own muse and still seemingly make some sort of living.   Check out these selections,  Soul Desert,  Gimme Back my FlagHard ShoulderJulian H CopePristeen / Hanging out and Hung Up On The LineSafesurfer and Know (Cut My Friend Down)

And quite what Upwards at 45 degrees Means is anyone's guess!!!



Saturday, 22 November 2014

Song of the Day 36 : Paul Kelly : Bradman

Bradman is one of Paul Kelly's outstanding story songs.  I am not sure which one I prefer but to me it's a toss up between this and Other People's Houses.

Anyway I thought this would be a good "song" for the start of the Southern Summer.  

Favourites : Little Feat : Dixie Chicken

I did not really get into Little Feat until after they had well and truly peaked and Lowell George had left. I remember Doc Rock raving and repeatedly playing the Long Distance Love video on a Radio a with Puctures. Glad I was reassessed them later as they are such a great band and Dixie Chicken is in my opinion the best of their studio albums.

Full of smokey funk and swagger with an almost perfect first side.  From the classy opening title track - here in a great version with Emmylou and Bonnie Rait - through Two Trains, Roll um Easy (covered the same year by Glenn Campbell), the definitive version of Allen Toussaint's On Your Way Down and then closing out with the slow groove of Kiss it Off.

The only problem with the quality of side one is that I do not flip the record often enough.  Why come down after that high?  But there are still gems there with Fat Man in Bathtub and Lafayette Railroad.

Friday, 21 November 2014

Favourites : The Colourfield : Virgins and Philistine

For a while in the 1980s it looked like Terry Hall was on a path to deliberately sabotage any career success he had.  First he left The Specials when they were at the top of their game to work with  Neville Staple and Lynval Golding in Funboy 3 which he immediately disbanded after the success of Waiting to form what was orginally a very acoustic and almost folky The Colourfield.

While my flatmates at uni were quite into The Specials I always preferred The Beat.  I therefore did not start to fully appreciate Hall until Funboy 3 (whom I wrote about here).

No one else could sing so dead pan and almost disinterested.  He is both nothing like and very similar to Leonard Cohen in that way.  On slower numbers his singing slightly behind the beat is also similar in ways to Willie Nelson's approach.

Virgins and Philistines was released in 1985 and I bought it after being given a copy of the eponymous single by the folks that owned The Everyman in Nelson. They would occasionally give me records in the hope that it would prompt bigger purchases - and it worked.


This is now the Terry Hall album I return to the most.  Its simplicity means that, along with The Specials' first album I think it has aged best of all his albums.  One of Hall's best lyrical abilities is to be able to in some nice, and frequently droll couplets, sum up some complex human emotions and situations.
" I guess I kind of should have knew
I should be thinking of you
But a friendship's built on trust 
and that is something that you never do" 
From Thinking of You


Highlights for me on this album are Yours Sincerely, The Hammond Song (a Roches' cover), Take, Castles in the Air and Thinking of You.  But it certainly seems that Hall is always struggling in relationships.

I finally managed to see Terry Hall with the Specials about 3 years ago in Singapore - good show but I have to admit that You Dun too Much Much Too Young sung by a 50 year old has a completely different vibe to when it was sung by a 19 year old.

Wednesday, 19 November 2014

Song of the Day 59 : Nick Cave Into My Arms

I really only started to listen to Nick Cave in earnest when I bought this great Best of  set.  I had heard The Birthday Party way back in Uni days and was never that impressed.  I had heard odd solo tracks and probably an album or two all the way through at friends but never really committed to finding out more.  So the Best of was a good way to dip my toe in the water.

The Best Of set also came with a great live CD which showed how some of the songs converted live.

All this meant that I have since gone on to collecting quite a lot of Nick's back catalogue and many of his releases since.  Not to mention having watched the movies he has written screenplays for.

Like Waits Nick Cave is as good on the soft ballad as he is on the raucous noise.  Into My Arms is an excellent esample of the former.  His religious imagery is consistent in both with hell and redemption, whether Christian or mythical. figuring often and even if he does not believe in an Interventionist God something inspired him on this one.


"Into My Arms"

I don't believe in an interventionist God
But I know, darling, that you do
But if I did I would kneel down and ask Him
Not to intervene when it came to you
Not to touch a hair on your head
To leave you as you are
And if He felt He had to direct you
Then direct you into my arms

Into my arms, O Lord
Into my arms, O Lord
Into my arms, O Lord
Into my arms

And I don't believe in the existence of angels
But looking at you I wonder if that's true
But if I did I would summon them together
And ask them to watch over you
To each burn a candle for you
To make bright and clear your path
And to walk, like Christ, in grace and love
And guide you into my arms

Into my arms, O Lord
Into my arms, O Lord
Into my arms, O Lord
Into my arms

And I believe in Love
And I know that you do too
And I believe in some kind of path
That we can walk down, me and you
So keep your candles burning
And make her journey bright and pure
That she will keep returning
Always and evermore

Into my arms, O Lord
Into my arms, O Lord
Into my arms, O Lord
Into my arms

Tuesday, 18 November 2014

Song of the Day 35 : Angel From Montgomery : John Prine : Bonnie Raitt and others

Some male songwriters manage to write great songs from a Woman's perspective. John Prine certainly captured the lost hopes of a marriage lost in mundane routine that has not delivered on its expectations.  Bonnie Raitt certainly made Angel From Montgomery her own when she recorded it and you can hear the resigned disappointment of those last four lines.

But how the hell can a person
Go on to work in the morning
To come home in the evening
And have nothing to say

Something I try hard not to each day







                                                          "Angel From Montgomery"

I am an old woman
Named after my mother
An old man is another
Child who's grown old

If dreams were thunder
Lightning was desire
This old house it would've burned down
A long time ago

[Chorus:]
Make me an angel
That flies from montgomery
Make me a poster
Of an old rodeo
Just give me one thing
That i can hold on to
To believe in this livin'
Is just a hard way to go

When i was a young girl
I had me a cowboy
It wasn't much to look at
It was a free ramblin' man
There was a long time
No matter how i tried
The years they just rolled by
Like a broken down dance

[Chorus]

There's flies in the kitchen
I can hear them there buzzin'
And i ain't done nothing since i woke up today
But how the hell can a person
Go on to work in the morning
To come home in the evening
And have nothing to say

[Chorus]

Monday, 17 November 2014

Tom Waits Part 1 : Probably My Favouirite Song Writer and Artist


One tenet that I have always held onto is that you do not need to have a great voice to be a great singer.  In fact hardly any of the singers I really enjoy have great voices. Somehow great voices and emotional depth do not often combine.  However I can say categorically that Tom Waits is a great singer and  an even better songwriter.

Tom Waits started eeking his way into my life in 1977 when I bought, Small Change.  I was in my last year of high school and at that stage was in a no man's land between the Old Wave and the New Wave.

At that time Tom Waits was like nothing else in my collection and to a certain  extent he still is unique in the collection.  I had bought it solely for the almost novelty track The Piano Has Been Drinking. Something different to play as my friends and I played pool late at night when the song should probably have been retitled The Pool Cue's been drinking.

One thing I remember at the time was that NO ONE ELSE seemed to get Tom Waits apart from that one song.  I was on my own.

That first record also had the magnificent Tom Traubert's Blues (or as many know it Waltzing Mathilda).  Rod Stewart has tried covering Waits a few times and while I have great respect for Stewart's interpretative singing ability - his version of this is just bloody awful.  His approach toward Downtown Train (with Jeff Beck on guitar is much more creditable.

I remember at the time saying that I would probably only ever have one or two albums by him as I did not think his music would have lasting appeal or enough variation to sustain many more. How wrong I was and I am now the proud owner of about 50 records, cds and DVDs by the man. Up there with what I have by Neil Young, Elvis Costello, Willie Nelson, Dylan and Bowie - but unlike the others the only reason I do not have more by Tom is that he has not made more.  I also have some terrific albums of other artists interpreting his songs (the best of which are probably Temptation by Holy Cole and Southside Johnny's big band interpretations Grapefruit Moon).

A lot of people categorise Waits' career into two distinct phases.  The first the boho barfly period where Waits seemed like a musical cross between Jack Kerouac and Charles Bukowski.  The second being the more sonically experimental period.  The latter seemed to kick off when he met his wife Kathleen Brennan on the set of One From The Heart for which he was writing the soundtrack.  The movie was a flop but the soundtrack is outstanding and it did have Nastasia Kinski in it so it could not have been all bad!

However I do not think that there is as much difference between the two phases as people tend to say.  All he really did in my opinion was add some extra noise (in addition to his voice :-) ) to the melodies and take things a little lo-fi.

With Waits' music it is always the melodies that get to me - buried not far beneath growl, they are always there and when combined with his lyrics you get what is one of the most memorable songbooks since the great American Song Book was invented by Cole Porter, Rogers and Hammerstein and Gershwin.  He is of course a great story teller as well and whether the stories are told in song or in the between song banter makes no difference.  He has even specifically recorded some like his reminiscing about all the family cars in The Pontiac what a great story and so real!

Waits lyrics are, in my opinion,  some of  the most complete lyrics ever written.  What I mean by that is that they stand along as lyrics, present complete stories or situations and it seems that each word is specifically chosen and fitted like a complex jig-saw puzzle.  Certainly many stand reading alone without the music - quite unusual in rock lyrics.  There is obvious craftsmanship at work.

Another common theme with Waits is the calibre of the musicians he attracts - always a good sign when there is real talent at work.  Waits' roll call includes the likes of guitar supremos Keith Richard and Marc Ribot, Shelly Mann on Drums, Victor Feldman, Greg Cohen and Larry Taylor on Bass, Teddy Edwards on Sax and Bette Midler and Crystal Gayle on vocals,

It is very hard for me to pick a favourite Waits' album.  I come back to all of them frequently and Jan gets tired of changing from Waits on the car stereo.  Anyway here they are my favourite Waits' albums in  the order they were released.

Closing Time was his first album and many do not rate it but it is certainly in my top 5 Waits albums. Waits says he never liked the arrangements.  He was already wise beyond his years and writing songs that seemed to come from someone much older than his 22 years at the time.  Sure he has written some better songs but not much better.

The romantiscm of Martha, an old lover ringing what seems like the love of his life after a gap of 40 years or so.  Then there is the barroom romance of I Hope That I Don't Fall in Love with You, Ol' 55 - another car song (and the song that Waits claimed put his kids through school when The Eagles covered it on their first album. Then there is Grapefruit Moon.


Closing Time was followed by fan favourite The Heart of Saturday Night, the live album of new songs Nighthawks at The Diner and my introduction to his work Small Change.

Foreign Affair, the album after Small Change has some of my favourite songs with some of Waits' best lyrics. The title track stands out for what I consider some of the best lyrics ever written and a great example of what I call complete lyrics.







Foreign Affair
"When traveling abroad in the continental style

It's my belief one must attempt to be discreet
And subsequently bear in mind your transient position
Allows you a perspective that's unique

And though you'll find your itinerary's a blessing and a curse
Your wanderlust won't let you settle down
And you'll wonder how you ever fathomed that you'd be content
To stay within the city limits of a small Midwestern town
Most vagabonds I know don't ever want to find the culprit
That remains the object of their long relentless quest
The obsession's in the chasing not the apprehending
The pursuit you see and never the arrest
Without fear of contradiction "bon voyage" is always hollered
In conjunction with a handkerchief from shore
By a girl who drives a rambler and furthermore
Is overly concerned that she won't see him anymore
Planes and trains and boats and buses
Characteristically evoke a common attitude of blue
Unless you have a suitcase and a ticket and a passport
And the cargo that they're carrying is you
A foreign affair juxtaposed with a stateside
And domestically approved romantic fancy
Is mysteriously attractive due to circumstances knowing
It will only be parlayed into a memory

The album after Foreign Affair,  Blue Valentine was the last of his full fledged barfly albums and probably the most popular of the early albums. The song titles say it all, A Sweet Little Bullet from a Pretty Blue Gun, Christmas Card from a Hooker in Minneapolis, Whistling Past The Grave Yard are all terrific tracks and I often wonder why I do not play it more often.

Things started to change after this album and I was fortunate enough to see him soon after when he played the Wellington Town Hall.

More of that to come.



Song of the Day 34 : The Road to Peace : Tom Waits

Tom Waits is not known for political or what they used to call topical songs.  However he changed all that when he released Road to Peace on his Triple CD wrap up of off-cuts Orphans:  Brawlers, Bawlers and Bastards.  While you could say that Waits' buried the song among the 64 tracks on the set Road to Peace was immediately noticed by critics and fans alike.

While the reference to Bush dates the writing of the song it nevertheless captures the issues on both sides.  The Muslim Mother who raises her son well and is unaware that he has been radicalised, the eye for an eye reaction which leaves no way to break the cycle.


Road To Peace


Young Abdel Mahdi (Shahmay) was only 18 years old,

He was the youngest of nine children, never spent a night away from home.
And his mother held his photograph, opening the New York Times
To see the killing has intensified along the road to peace

There was a tall, thin boy with a whispy moustache disguised as an orthodox Jew
On a crowded bus in Jerusalem, some had survived World War Two
And the thunderous explosion blew out windows 200 yards away
With more retribution and seventeen dead along the road to peace

Now at King George Ave and Jaffa Road passengers boarded bus 14a
In the aisle next to the driver Abdel Mahdi (Shahmay)
And the last thing that he said on earth is "God is great and God is good"
And he blew them all to kingdom come upon the road to peace

Now in response to this another kiss of death was visited upon
Yasser Taha, Israel says is an Hamas senior militant
And Israel sent four choppers in, flames engulfed, tears wide open
And it killed his wife and his three year old child leaving only blackened skeletons

It's found his toddlers bottle and a pair of small shoes and they waved them in front of the cameras
But Israel says they did not know that his wife and child were in the car
There are roadblocks everywhere and only suffering on TV
Neither side will ever give up their smallest right along the road to peace

Israel launched it's latest campaign against Hamas on Tuesday
Two days later Hamas shot back and killed five Israeli soldiers
So thousands dead and wounded on both sides most of them middle eastern civilians
They fill the children full of hate to fight an old man's war and die upon the road to peace

"And this is our land we will fight with all our force" say the Palastinians and the Jews
Each side will cut off the hand of anyone who tries to stop the resistance
If the right eye offends thee then you must pluck it out
And Mahmoud Abbas said Sharon had been lost out along the road to peace

Once Kissinger said "we have no friends, America only has interests"
Now our president wants to be seen as a hero and he's hungry for re-election
But Bush is reluctant to risk his future in the fear of his political failures
So he plays chess at his desk and poses for the press 10,000 miles from the road to peace

In the video that they found at the home of Abdel Mahdi (Shahmay)
He held a Kalashnikov rifle and he spoke with a voice like a boy
He was an excellent student, he studied so hard, it was as if he had a future
He told his mother that he had a test that day out along the road to peace

The fundamentalist killing on both sides is standing in the path of peace
But tell me why are we arming the Israeli army with guns and tanks and bullets?
And if God is great and God is good why can't he change the hearts of men?
Well maybe God himself is lost and needs help
Maybe God himself he needs all of our help
Maybe God himself is lost and needs help
He's out upon the road to peace

Well maybe God himself is lost and needs help
Maybe God himself he needs all of our help
And he's lost upon the road to peace
And he's lost upon the road to peace
Out upon the road to peace.

Sunday, 16 November 2014

The Upside of Down : Trying to understand why depressing music is sometimes just the right tonic

This week I was invited to contribute to Blog on the Tracks a daily blog on Fairfax Media's website Stuff.  Here is my contribution


I have often wondered why I am drawn to sad, and some would even say depressing songs and music.  I know I am not the only one as there are so many such songs to choose from.  In fact if I am in a real funk I will reach for something with a title like Looking Up (for the next thing that brings me down) rather than Walking on Sunshine. The latter while a great song would never cheer me up – I would only ever play it at a party.  


Many people are drawn to Country, Soul and the Blues and if the music is so depressing why does listening to them not lead to rafts of suicide?

There is of course the myth around Gloomy Sunday, the Hungarian Suicide Song – that if you listened to the song you would commit suicide.  This even spawned a movie of the same name that became Christchurch’s longest running movie.  I have never been quite sure what that tells us about the people of Christchurch.

In this blog I am going to try and explore the phenomena I experience, how alone I am in it and then share some of my favourite downer songs in the hope of cheering you all up.

To get started I headed down to the local Google library and let my fingers do the walking to some more research. Then Simon also posted a link on Facebook so I was able to follow a new trail and get some more insights. 

All of this provided some interesting reading of which to be honest I did not understand too much. So in the spirit of 21st Century Journalism I looked for soundbites that would explain everything.  Latest Neuroscience research apparently all points to great advances in understanding.  A bunch of Danes came up with Music in Minor Activates Limbic Structures : A relationship with dissonance? another Japanese study concluded that Sad Music Induces Pleasant Emotions basically postulating that because we expect to hear sad things that makes us happy. 

Study from the University of Limerick that asked pretty much the same question concluded among other things that sad music provided a connection to what the listener was feeling and so provided companionship at a time when it was needed.   Perhaps the folks from Limerick could just have well have written -

There was an old man feeling down
The last thing he felt like was going to town
So be put on some blues and his dancing shoes 
and changed from a goose to a clown
(avoiding the obvious “and changed to a smile from a frown”)

However I think I finally latched onto what my reaction was all about in the following two studies.  First a study based on an online survey that identified amongst other things that “a high number of participants reported listening to sad music in situations of emotional distress or when they’re feeling lonely, so it could be a form of self-medication. And for most of the people, the engagement with sad music in everyday life is correlated with its potential to regulate negative moods and emotions, as well as to provide consolation,” 

This study referenced another piece of research by David Huron from University of Ohio in which he identified a link in some people to sad music and the release of prolactin a hormone associated with enhancing pleasurable responses. Interestingly he also found that I am not alone in my enjoyment of sad music in fact more than 2/3 of those in the study identified with the statement that “I enjoy listening to sad music”.  The percentage is interesting and so maybe there is a link between us Sad Music Junkies and National winning the last election. Ten Percent of those in the study agreed with the statement that “Sad Music was the music I most enjoy” and approximately 1/3 of the study concluding that they really did not enjoy Sad Music”. 

So there it is folks ….  My listening to music in general and sad music in particular is me satisfying my junkie like need for prolactin injected by means of depressing music.

And now the junkie is going to become a pusher – maybe so as I am not alone, maybe so we can share needles and you can pass on your tips for some music you think may cheer me up even more.

So here goes it goes Sludgie’s guide to the best music to cheer you up.  It was hard to pick just a few from the 1000’s of songs I have and I am sure you can think of plenty others. 

·         I feel I have to start with this album.  Jeff Klein's Everyone Loves A Winner.  I do not think I have anything grimmer and more likely to lift my spirits than side one of this album from Everything is Alright (and it’s clearly not), California through to Another Breakdown.  The other day it was playing in my office (in my continuing battle with tinitis) and a colleague came in and commented that’s really depressing and walked out – I guess he is not one of the 66%.    I suspect that when I hear all that angst played in sequence I get the feeling "poor bastard" aren't I lucky ..........................and I feel good. 
·         It does seem that while many of us might feel better after listening to sad music it may not be the same for those writing it.  Joy Division’s Love will Tear us Apart is a case in point and we lost Ian Curtis not long after.  About the time it was released a friend and I both agreed over a beer that we would love to hear Marvin Gaye sing this and not long after Marvin was gone too. While it makes me sad to think about Ian and Marvin – listening to this makes me feel good.
·         Ryan Adams first solo album is a great collection of songs that reflected his mood after the breakup of what must have been a pretty intense relationship.  He wears his heart in his sleeve on Come Pick Me Up and demonstrates the thin line between love and hate in those times.  When I listen to this I think glad that’s not me and ……. I feel good.
·         Terry Hall from The Specials, Fun Boy Three and The Colourfield seems a pretty glum fellow.  Take is excellent example of he can deconstruct a relationship breakdown and help me …….. feel good.
·         Paul Westerburg is one of the most under-rated songwriters around – while he has written some great dumb rock songs – he has also a fine collection of songs that are designed to make you feel better by sharing his bad luck or current problems.  A favourite of mine is Here Comes A Regular.  While I wouldn’t mind a drink in that bar I feel good that I am not that regular.
·         Keep Me in Your Heart : Warren Zevon’s last recorded song – for such an irascible bastard he sure faced death with dignity and basically wrote his own obituary ……………  to think of how we could face death with humour and dignity makes me feel good.
·         Not surprisingly I am a big fan of what some call Gothic Country.  Its exponents include The Handsome Family, Sixteen Horsepower, Johnny Dowd and my favourite Jim White.  His The Wound That Never Heals could be the screenplay to one dark movie and listening to it certainly tells me that life can be worse than bad and reminds me that mine is not…………… so I feel good
·         One of the saddest songs I know is Tom Waits’ On the Nickel where Tom pays respects to those hobos and homeless on 5th St in Los Angeles.  He seems to ponder how they got there and he did not. He does it with dignity and respect and that makes me feel good that that can be done.
·         The problem I had here was limiting the selection.  There are many, many more whether they be by Leonard Cohen, more Tom Waits,  – but maybe save those for a rainy day when I need cheering up.

But finally there has to be an exception to prove the rule

·         Strange Fruit   Billy Holiday’s graphic description of lynching in the South.  While I play Billie and this song regularly it does not lift my spirits, it makes me feel …………. ANGRY